It's 3 p.m., oppressively
hot, and the coffee ran out half an hour ago.
Still, the energy level is sky-high in the
conference room where Sandia National
Laboratories' internal Web team is thrashing out
schedules and strategies for the coming year.
Legs jiggle, pencils tap; people interrupt one
another or cross the room to crouch beside a
colleague's chair and argue in emphatic
whispers.
Project leader Karen Long is so absorbed in the
proceedings that she doesn't even notice when a
bug the size of a small dog crawls into her
computer case. Waving a fat red marker, she
calls out the next agenda item: "Page submittal
process everybody's
favorite. How do we rank it?" "High!" "High!"
"High!" call out various team members. "Low!"
yells a lone dissenter. "We already have a
process."
"Yes," says Long, "we have a process, but we
don't have one for casual, infrequent users. So
maybe for the ones who know what they're doing,
we give them an account, and those who don't
have the knowledge can come to us."
Someone else chimes in: "What I've been hearing
from the technical people is they want something
simple, a slam-bang way of putting stuff on the
server. If we make it too hard, they're just
going to say Ôscrew this' and go out and get
their own, and we'll end up with thousands of
servers."
"OK," says Long, making a few quick marks on the
list of priorities taped to the wall. "We'll say
high, but let's keep the costs in mind."
And so it goes for
another two hours and two dozen agenda items.
The meeting, taking place several miles from
Sandia's home on the Kirkland Air Force base in
Albuquerque, N.M., has brought together members
of the lab's imperfectly acronymed EVE team
(Enterprisewide-information Viewing Environment)
with trainers, internal consultants and liaisons
to the information-provider community. These 20
people have until Feb. 1, 1996, to resolve a
slew of Web-related issues and get all of
Sandia's administrative materials online. In the
process, they are using a very new technology to
chase some old organizational hares, including
ubiquitous information, cross-platform
communications and the ever-elusive paperless
office.
The EVE project with
its emphasis on internal communication and
absence of external marketing goals is
atypical of current Web initiatives. But that's
going to change: In a recent survey of more than
150 companies, the Business Research Group of
Newton, Mass., found 23 percent had implemented
or planned to implement internal Web sites and
another 20 percent were thinking about it. For
now, most of the innovators in this area are
high-tech companies or public/private hybrids
like Sandia, which conducts projects for the
Department of Energy and other government
agencies but is managed by Lockheed Martin. Such
organizations are focused more on cutting costs
and bureaucracy internally than on captivating
the world at large. (Sandia does have an
external Web site at http://www.sandia.gov, but
it is a separate project and not as elaborate as
the internal system.)
But in other ways, Sandia's experience with the
Web is not so unusual. As in most organizations,
its road to Damascus began in the engineering
department, where Fran Current was on a team
investigating ways to apply the principles of
electronic commerce to the organization's
dealings with electronic-components suppliers.
"We looked at VANs, we looked at the Internet,
and that's when we stumbled across the World
Wide Web," says Current, who is co-leader of the
EVE team (ask a Sandian for anything like a
formal title and the response is typically
polite bafflement). "Immediately upon seeing
what the Web was capable of, I realized that was
what we needed at Sandia for an internal
information system."
This was about 18 months ago, and major changes
in the organization's information architecture
were already afoot. Sandia had just boosted Mike
Eaton out of the electrical engineering ranks to
become its first-ever CIO, with a mandate to
create a coherent, corporatewide network from
the existing jumble of LANs running on a mix of
PCs, Macs and Unix machines. The e-mail
situation (six incompatible systems and nearly
100 post offices) was symptomatic of the chaos
Eaton hoped to dispel. "With all these local
solutions, people were using e-mail
inappropriately, as a means of sharing data
within their enterprises," he says. "They were
trying to make a freight hauler out of a
notification device."
The new CIO barely had time to settle into his
office before Sandia's Web evangelists came
knocking on his door. "I took one look [at the
Web] and I said, ÔThat's our freight hauler!'"
recalls Eaton.
Having blessed the Web
as Sandia's best hope for a corporate
communications vehicle, Eaton established a core
team of eight people (Current and a few other
engineers actually transferred into IS) and told
them to go forth and build prototypes. Eschewing
the need for elaborate cost justifications, he
readily agreed to fund the project at roughly
one million dollars a year. "My philosophy has
been to try to avoid getting myself involved in
ROI until people can actually see and feel what
the capabilities are," says Eaton. "If you get
all hung up on that you may get yourself
started, but the sword will come back and kill
you, as the overall cost rises with the addition
of capabilities and services."
Thus anointed, the EVE team rapidly arranged
TCP/IP installation training for Sandia's LAN
managers, who then fanned out across the
organization delivering Web connectivity
wherever they went. By late summer,
approximately 6,000 of Sandia's 10,000 employees
and contractors had Web access: The goal is 100
percent penetration for regular computer users.
(Computerless Sandians, such as forklift
operators and machinists, will be able to get at
the Web through standalone kiosks supplied by
Lockheed Martin as part of an ethics training
program.) As for the corporate Web servers,
Eaton directed that they be established in
Sandia's brand-new customer service units
(CSUs), geographic divisions created to serve as
focal points for network management.
Meanwhile, the team's programmers were working
on getting the newly Web-enabled something to
access, starting with a searchable corporate
phone directory and a property-management
application that enables employees to track
computers and other inventory registered in
their names. When this information lived on
Sandia's mainframe, "access was very
complicated, and only 2,500 people could get at
it directly," says Current. "I didn't have a
mainframe account, so if I wanted to get my
property information I had to go to my
organization's property coordinator and that
person would get on the mainframe, generate a
report, print it out and give it to me. Now I
can go directly to the Web and get it, along
with 6,300 other people." (Another advantage:
Web applications are very easy to write. Senior
Analyst Pat Milligan, who created Sandia's
conference-room scheduler, says that writing a
similar program for the mainframe would have
taken at least four times as long.)
But while these first applications aimed at
bringing mass exposure to formerly reclusive
databases, EVE never lost sight of the real
enemy. "It's paper," explains Rich Graham, who,
as executive coordinator for information
providers, helps groups and individuals get
their materials online. "We have these manuals:
corporate procedures and policies, environmental
safety and health, travel, compensation,
procurement, and on and on. There's a whole
shelf of this stuff, and every manager has to
have them, and every manager has to add paper
updates sometimes
two or three a month. Some people would actually
print the entire manual over again" every time
new information was added.
It is these 30 or so manuals that EVE plans to
make Web-accessible by February, as an icon
under the "Administrative" label on Sandia's
internal home page. Other applications in that
category include "Communications" (special
reports and regular publications);
"Applications" (conference-room scheduling,
order-tracking, etc.); "Corporate Policy"
(vision, mission support, etc.); "Organizations"
and "Services." Users can also access
information from the technical side of the
house, although "to this point we have hit the
administrative side more heavily," says Eaton.
But as the administrative task is completed,
EVE's attention is turning back toward
applications that would, for example, enable
technicians to share drawing packages over the
Web, or post animated mechanical designs. "The
Web here had its roots in engineering if
just barely and
now it's our job to get those people back into
it," says Eaton.
But the Web isn't just
something you build, it's something you live
with. While EVE wrestled with brick-and-mortar
issues of security, archiving and server
configuration, others were questioning how Web
information should be managed and presented, and
how the new technology could be made most useful
to internal customers.
Out of these concerns was born WebCo, a service
organization that acts as a consultant for
groups putting material on the Web and educates
Sandians about things like common look and feel
and writing for online consumption. "EVE is like
Ford Motor Co. in Detroit and [WebCo. is] like
Rich Ford here in Albuquerque the
distributor who services the cars and makes sure
the customer is happy," explains Jennie Negin,
manager of WebCo. "They do the engineering; we
do the applying. They do the technology; we do
the information management."
When Negin talks about "Information" you can
hear the capital "I" in her voice. That may be
the legacy of years spent managing corporate
libraries, an experience that has also largely
formed her take on the Web, which she believes
fulfills a similar function. "Much of library
work is really brokering information," Negin
explains. "The librarian doesn't say, well, this
piece of information is formal and this piece is
informal; and that's internal and that's
external; and that's computer- based and that's
on paper. No, the librarian listens to the
information you need and uses the appropriate
resources to give it to you. And that's what the
Web does."
But that model only works when information is
presented thoughtfully, with an eye toward how
and by whom it will be used. WebCo's mission is
twofold: to help information providers design
and implement effective pages (or to do it for
them, for a chargeback fee) and to train them in
subjects as mundane as browser usage (Sandia
supports both Netscape and Spyglass) and as
esoteric as "hyperthinking." The hyperthink
class, which is currently in development, aims
to get people past the
one-information-format-fits-all mind-set. "The
universities have taught us to write these 20-
and 30-page papers, and somewhere in there is
buried a piece of useful information," says Web
Training Coordinator and Instructor Tamara Orth,
one of five training consultants and developers.
"We're trying to get people to identify that
piece of useful information, extract it, and
that's what they put up there."
But short and sweet is only part of it. "We took
this technology that for science and research
could be very free and open, and we started
using it for administration," says Negin. "That
meant it had to be predictable." Predictability,
for Sandia, means consistent information page
title, page creator, page owner and review date in
a consistent position on every document. That
review date, by the way, is a kind of freshness
stamp, to alert content owners when something
they've posted is getting a little overripe.
"It's the responsibility of the owners to
maintain their documents, but I know myself that
I've put things on the Web and forgotten they
were there," says Graham. "Our vision is that we
will have a script file that will go out and
look at the review date and then fire the owner
an e-mail notification" if the date has expired.
Another brow-furrowing issue is not
surprisingly security.
A proxy server stands between internal users and
the badlands of the Internet at large; the
machine keeps intruders at bay and filters
potentially dangerous files that might harbor a
virus. But the Web group is also evaluating
authentication and security software for
internal use, so that employees can update their
own training and personnel records without
worrying that someone's going to sneak in and
erase a couple of zeros off their salaries, as
well as get access to management information and
sensitive stuff like weapons data. Currently,
certain human resources records are available on
a read-only basis; other applications rely on
the honor system. "You just have to hope that if
you use the conference-room scheduler to arrange
something, someone else doesn't go in there and
unarrange it, because basically they can," says
Orth.
EVE co-leader Long
says that resolving some of these problems and
keeping the Web development process on track has
had a unifying effect on Sandians. The Web group
presides over periodic meetings of information
providers some
of whom had never previously met to
discuss differing interpretations of the
policies and procedures being posted. In order
to achieve a consistent presentation, for
example, departmental financial officers have
had to stop using terms to mean whatever they
want them to mean and instead work together on a
set of common definitions. "They have to get
together on these things so people have a basis
to talk to one another," says Long. "This is the
first time there's been a mechanism for that to
happen."
The Web has also furthered integration of
Sandia's Albuquerque campus with a much smaller
site in Livermore, Calif. (The two are connected
by similar projects, a common culture and a T3
line.) "The Web allows a diverse population to
access applications and documents across
platforms and across sites in a way that
probably wouldn't be possible anywhere else
except in a small company," says Tracy Walker, a
senior member of the technical staff in
California. "It reinforces the fact that we are
all one Sandia."
- Leigh Buchanan
Inside Moves
A portfolio of diverse
applications aims to make the Web a one-stop
information resource
EVE Project Leader
Fran Current sounds like he's speaking for the
whole team when he describes his goals for the
internal Web initiative: "I would like to see
the Web become the single, virtual source for
all information within Sandia, the first place
somebody looks when they need to know
something." In addition to posting things like
policy manuals and vacation balances, the Web
group has developed some ingenious applications
that go a long way toward making that vision a
reality. Here are a few:
Conference-Room Scheduling: All
conference rooms at Sandia are not created
equal. That's hardly surprising when you
consider that the sprawling campus is a
patchwork of comfortable offices, bleak
technical buildings and remote trailers.
Employees wishing to reserve just the right
venue for their meeting can now do so over the
Web, by plugging in their social security
numbers and choosing from a list of several
dozen specifications (overhead projector,
whiteboard, handicapped access, coffee pot,
etc.) Senior analyst Pat Milligan hopes to
enhance the program by enabling users to
schedule multiple rooms for multiple days and by
posting photos of the 50-or-so available spaces.
Financial-Management Query: This
project-management tool enables users to enter a
project case number and find out immediately how
much is being spent on procurement, labor and
other factors. "In the past, if I wanted this
information I had to go to an administrative
assistant who had an account on the mainframe to
get it for me," says Current. Other internal
tracking tools remind employees what inventory
they are responsible for (and where it resides)
and check on the status of anything they may
have ordered.
Knowledge Preservation: Like any
venerable organization, Sandia possesses a
wealth of information and experience that
resides principally in the heads of its
employees. In order not to lose this resource as
people retire, the organization is videotaping
departing staff members as they hold forth on
their areas of expertise, then putting
transcripts of those sessions on the Web. (As
the EVE team increases its use of video, it may
make the taped versions available online as
well.)
Official Airline Guide: This
application might more aptly be named the
Official All-Travel Guide, since it includes
car-rental and hotel-availability information as
well as everything you ever wanted to know about
airline schedules. (For security reasons,
employees can't yet use the guide to make
reservations.) Milligan hopes to add
foreign-travel authorization to the
application's capabilities: The current process
involves routing paperwork to six different
people.
Subscription Service: Now that Sandia
is putting its manuals, Weekly Bulletin and
other publications on the Web, employees no
longer get the paper versions pushed at them all
the time. Concerned that the
out-of-sight/out-of-mind rule might mean
information getting overlooked or ignored, the
Web group created an online subscription
service. Through the Web, employees simply
indicate which publications they're interested
in; then, when an update or new edition is
posted they are notified immediately via e-mail.
SAND Reports: Whenever researchers
make a discovery or complete a project, they
generate SAND reports, which are like scientific
journal articles for internal reference. The
paper versions are housed in the corporate
library, but online abstracts searchable by key
words are now being placed on the Web.
-L. Buchanan
Paper View
Can the Web truly be the
paperless dream fulfilled?
Creating the paperless
office is like balancing the federal budget:
Almost everyone says they want to get there, but
saying it is easier than doing it. And then, of
course, there are the cranky few who argue that
it's not worth doing in the first place. "The
Web is in place, and we want to use it to the
maximum extent that we can, but that doesn't
mean we're going to quit publishing paper," says
Larry Perrine, Sandia's manager of employee
communications. "Some people will use it; some
people won't."
That's more than just an educated guess:
Perrine recently asked a random sample of
employees if they preferred reading Sandia's
Weekly Bulletin on the company's Web site or on
paper paper
won out by a margin of three-to-two. In
addition, only 40 percent of employees who knew
that the Bulletin was on the Web had actually
read it there.
Still, more folks are starting to come
around. Last spring, when Perrine first
announced the availability of the Bulletin on
the Web, about 10 percent of Sandia's employees
and contractors asked that they no longer
receive it through their mailboxes. That means a
10 percent smaller printing run and a consequent
cost savings. "We're on an educational curve,
and as people get trained on this, I'm sure
we'll be able to make further cuts," says
Perrine. (Interestingly, Sandia's much smaller
California site has had better luck with online
delivery. A daily newsletter sent by e-mail and
posted on the Web has completely replaced the
old paper version, reducing paper distribution
to the tune of about 13,000 pages a week.)
Perrine also expects usage to rise as the Web
becomes a more effective vehicle for news
delivery. Already it is being used to supplement
major announcements; when Sandia's new president
was named in August, for example, employees
could turn to the Web for press releases that
were formerly seen only by media outlets. It may
also help fill the void that would be created if
the organization's radio station closes next
year, leaving readers to click on rather than
tune in. |